I have a really hard time choosing between two things that I want desperately. I'm not logical in the least and so pros and cons are never scratched down on paper. I always go with gut or heart. Is this what I want to do? Do I feel good about it? Done.
And so, when I moved from the sprawling countryside where I grew up, to New York City, I never thought I was leaving anything behind. My mother was still in the country and I could go there whenever I pleased. My father was at the time living in Los Angeles. I had two escapes from New York City life; a quick zip to upstate New York to get lost in the woods that surrounded my Mother's house, and a longer flight to California to sit by the ocean or dabble my toes in cool pool water. New York friends talked about getting out of the city like it was some sort of science experiment, confusing and stressful but above all else very intriguing.
These same New York friends told me I was lucky to have my family outside of the city and simultaneously so close by. They told me they would love to go upstate and get a break from their monotonous, crazy existence. I was lucky, but I still wasn’t choosing.
My first apartment in New York was a one bedroom on the upper west side with two of my best friends from childhood. We played a game of musical chairs sharing one bed and a pull out couch and talked about how glad we were to get out of that small town upstate. One of those friends and I had taken a break from school and gotten ourselves jobs, the third shuttled back and forth between our cluttered apartment and a New York college life. She made some friends at school. The three of us made friends collectively and invited them to our communal living space perched right above an ornery old spinster who would bang her broom against the ceiling whenever we threw a party. We viewed her as the a-typical stressed out New Yorker and turned up the music.
I commuted to a job in fashion in the meatpacking district working at a desk five days a week often feeling like a slacker. My coworkers sat at their desks well beyond any dinnertime I’d ever known and drank coffee by the truckload. I remember receiving an email from a coworker one evening. She shot me a glance from across the room as I scrolled down my screen reading the words “I’ve got to get out of here!” Who knows if she just meant for the day because she was running late for a dinner date or in life, but I took it as the latter. I sent a lengthy response, that I knew exactly how she felt, that working at a desk 10hrs a day didn’t seem like life to me and so on. She never responded. As we walked out of the office later that evening I brought up the email again, but somehow it seemed that I was now conversing with a different friend, not one who had just emailed me about her lack of zeal for life in general.
“I mean what else is there?” she said. At which point I knew I had over done it.
A few years later my father had moved back east settling with my step mother in Connecticut, just an hours drive from where I had moved to in Brooklyn. I didn’t share a one bedroom with two friends anymore but I still lived in an apartment surrounded by concrete and was awoken every morning by noise outside my window. I was now proud to say I was a New Yorker, as we all are, but in the back of my mind it never seemed definite. I could go back home anytime I wanted.
I still haven’t decided where I want to be, and the conclusion I’m slowly coming to is that I may never really decide. They both feel right. A friend who has moved out of New York for the West coast never really got over this city. Her home in California sits on a beautiful vineyard overlooking a lake with spacious land and animals and peace and quiet.
“I know it’s supposed to be beautiful,” she told me one evening over dinner, “and it is, but it just doesn’t do it for me. Show me a bunch of schoolgirls walking down the streets of New York holding hands, and that to me is beautiful. That takes my breath away.” And I remember agreeing with her, in public and in private, because I did love New York and still do. And maybe I used to feel bad for wanting too much; for wanting the peace of the countryside and the clatter of the city. And maybe, I just don’t want to choose.